According to the criminal complaint filed by Joe Smith, Josh Endicott and B.T. Sipple of the Mingo County Sheriff's Department, Hatfield, along with Michael Sturgell and a juvenile, stole a 2006 Honda all-terrain vehicle (ATV) and taken it back to Fort Gay. The ATV belonged to Danny Ferguson of Jennie's Creek and was valued at $5,000.
Magistrate Newsome set Hatfield's bail for $3,000. As of press time Hatfield had not posted bail.